is reader-supported. When you buy something through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases

Sweet or Dill Relish for Hot Dogs (Which One to Choose)

Last Update:

It can be confusing to choose the right kind of relish for your hotdog. And people get stuck the most between sweet and dill relish.

So, sweet or dill relish for hot dogs?

Choosing sweet or dill relish mostly depends on preferences. Dill relish is sourer than sweet relishes. Dill relish has more flavor while sweet relish can complement the sausage.  Both of the relishes are crunchy and give a balance of texture to your hotdog. 

Well, the above info isn’t everything. There are more than just sweet and sour differences between the relishes. Dive down for a better understanding and figure out your next pick. 

Which Relish Should You Go With?

Going between sweet or dill relish solely depends on your preference.

If you want to have better flavors and sournesses on your hotdog, we suggest using dill relish. Less sugar and more vinegar with dill give a better sweet and sour combination. It also has a more sophisticated note of flavor than sweet relish. 

But if you are up for only one flavor to go well with your hotdog, pick sweet relish. It’s seen that most people tend to use sweet relish on their hotdogs. 

Lastly, as we said earlier, it’s completely up to your preference. Both of the relishes aim to do the same task but in different ways. They add different flavoring to your hotdog. 

Differences Between Sweet and Dill Relish

Both of the relishes have almost similar recipes and ingredients. The big difference is the use of dill and the amount of sugar.

Sweet relish has a similar sour crunchy bite as dill relish. Since pickled cucumber and vinegar are really sour. Sweet relish has more sugar than dill relish.

On the other hand, in dill relish, we have relish that is dill. Here the sour taste mainly dominates. Also, there is less sugar and more vinegar. This makes the relish sourer than sweet relish. But, boiled vinegar has a slightly sweet note like white wine.  

Everyone has different preferences of dill. But most people tend to use sweet relish on their hotdogs.

Sweet Relish for Hotdogs

Sweet relishes are really popular. And people tend to use sweet relish more than any relish. Because people have an attraction towards sweetness. You can even use sweet relish with brisket-hot dogs. In that case, make sure to have the right color of brisket.

The sweet relish will pair up with your hotdog perfectly if you want a sweet bite in your hotdog. Dill relish tends to be really sour. So, if you don’t like sour, we suggest going with a sweet relish. 

Sweet relish also has that satisfying crunch like dill relish. It will compliment your meat of choice in hotdogs. Don’t use thickeners as you use thickeners on purees. For instance, queso can be thinned out. But why take the hassle right? If you use thickeners here, your hotdog will not have that satisfying crunch anymore. 

You can get sweet relishes at grocery stores. But it’s really easy to make at home.


How to Make Sweet Relish?

Sweet relish is really easy to make. You need some simple ingredients and the rest depends on your mixing skill. 

Things you’ll be needing 

  • ½ pound Pickled cucumber (chopped)
  • 1 onion (chopped)
  • 1 teaspoon salt 
  • 1 ½ cup Sugar
  • 1 cup of water
  • ½ cup Apple cider vinegar
  • ½ teaspoon Mustard seeds
  • ½ teaspoon Celery seeds
  • ½ cup of olive oil

If you are thinking of cucumber pickles, you can give these two pickles a try.


These two pickles are really good and have a good sour bite to them. 

Steps to follow

  1. Add pickled cucumbers, onions, and salt and rinse with water
  2. On the other side, add sugar, vinegar, mustard, and celery seed in a cooking pot. Then get it to a boil in a cup of water. Keep stirring otherwise the sugar will stick at the bottom. 
  3. Drain the pickles and onions and add them to the boiling pot. Boil it for 10 minutes
  4. Add olive oil to the mixture and keep it in a tight jar leaving at least ½ inch space above. 

Keep it in a dark space. It will stay good for a few weeks. This way you can make a sweet relish at home. 

Dill Relish for Hotdogs

On the other hand, we have dill relish. You might be wondering what Dill actually is? Dill is a type of herb-like celery. Dill relish has a sour bite to it, complementing your meat in the hotdog.

In comparison with the sweet relish ingredients, you just add dills here. Other ingredients and steps are the same. 

The taste of dill relish is different though. Dill relish is less sweet and comparatively sour. If you and your guest like to have a sour crunch in the hotdogs. We suggest you use dill relish. It also has the smell of dill in it. 

You can buy dill relish in the store. But making it is really easy and you can control the flavors.


How to Make Dill Relish

To make dill relish. You’ll be needing,

  • ½ pound Pickled cucumber (chopped)
  • ½ cup dill
  • 1 onion (chopped)
  • 1 teaspoon salt 
  • ½ cup Sugar
  • 1 cup of water
  • 1 cup Apple cider vinegar
  • ½ teaspoon Mustard seeds
  • ½ cup of olive oil

Steps to follow

  1. Get your picked cucumbers and onions in a pot and rinse them with water.
  2. On the other side, add salt, sugar, water, dill, vinegar, mustard seed to a pot. Get it to a boil for 10 to 15 minutes. 
  3. Add the cucumbers and onion to the boiled mixture. Let it boil for another 5 minutes.
  4. Add olive oil to the mixture and keep it in the tight jar

While boiling, take measures to stop the pan from sliding. Then, keep the jar in the refrigerator or in a dark place. It will stay good for a few weeks. In this way, you can make dill relish at home. Add it to your hotdog to enhance its flavors.


Are homemade relishes better than store-bought?

Yes. It is better because you can control the flavor and ingredients. You can make it the way you want.

Are relishes good for health?

Relishes do have vitamin C when they are freshly made. In general, they are not bad for your health. 

Can you use relish on burgers?

Yes. you can use relish on your burgers. You can use relish instead of pickles. It has better flavoring and taste to it. 

Final Words

So that is all you need to know when you sweet or dill relish for hot dogs. Hope that cleared any confusion on the matter. Also, use fresh products for better flavoring. 

Till next time, have a wonderful day.